Blog · Storm damage

Selling a hurricane-damaged house: repair, claim or sell as-is?

Three paths, and the insurance claim affects all of them. Deadlines, wind vs. flood, disclosure, and how to compare your options.

    Get your no-obligation offer

    A real person — usually Mike — calls you back the same day.

    Mike Youngblood

    Mike Youngblood, owner of A+ Home Buyers and a licensed Florida real estate agent. I've bought storm-damaged houses from owners who'd had enough. Here's how I'd think it through first. Last reviewed November 10, 2026

    A hurricane-damaged house gives you three basic paths: repair it, pursue an insurance claim, or sell it as-is. The insurance claim affects all three, because the coverage, payment, and mortgage requirements can change what you can afford to do. Before choosing, document the damage, understand what your policy covers, and get a realistic repair estimate.

    First Steps After Hurricane Damage

    Start with safety. Do not enter a building that may be structurally unsafe, and do not approach downed power lines or standing water that may be electrically energized.

    Document the damage before cleanup changes the evidence. Take photographs and video of each affected room, the roof, exterior walls, windows, flooring, contents, and any water line. Make a written inventory. If damaged items must be discarded for health or safety reasons, photograph them first.

    Take reasonable emergency steps to prevent additional damage. That may mean covering a roof opening, boarding a broken window, or arranging a professional to remove a dangerous tree limb. Keep receipts for materials and labor. Florida's Department of Financial Services specifically recommends documenting damage and repairs, making emergency repairs to prevent further damage, notifying the insurer, and keeping receipts and records of expenses. (Florida DFS)

    Report the loss to your insurance company or agent promptly. Keep a log of calls, emails, claim numbers, names, dates, and what each person tells you. Give the insurer access to inspect the damage and keep copies of estimates, reports, invoices, and written decisions. DFS's post-disaster claims guide recommends documenting the loss, making necessary emergency repairs, notifying the insurer, and keeping detailed notes and receipts. (Florida DFS)

    Do not sign a repair contract or an insurance-related assignment agreement just because someone says it is required to start work. Read the agreement. If it gives another company rights to insurance benefits or authority over your claim, have a Florida attorney review it.

    Wind Damage and Flood Damage Are Not the Same Claim

    A hurricane can cause several kinds of damage at once. Wind may remove shingles, break windows, or damage exterior walls. Rain may enter through an opening caused by wind. Floodwater may rise from a bay, river, canal, drainage ditch, or accumulated surface water.

    Those causes can be treated differently under insurance policies.

    Most homeowners and business insurance policies do not cover flood damage. Flood insurance is generally purchased separately, often through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or a private flood insurer. (Florida OIR)

    That distinction matters in a claim. A roof damaged by wind and a first floor inundated by rising water may involve different coverage, deductibles, adjusters, and policy terms. Do not assume that because a hurricane caused the damage, every part of the loss falls under the homeowners policy.

    The NFIP is administered by FEMA. A standard NFIP policy has its own coverage terms, limits, exclusions, proof-of-loss requirements, and mortgagee provisions. Review the actual policy and contact the flood insurer about the claim. (FEMA NFIP)

    If you have both a homeowners policy and a flood policy, report the loss to both insurers when the damage may involve both covered causes. Keep the estimates separated where possible. Ask each insurer to explain in writing which damage it attributes to wind, rain entering through a covered opening, flood, or another cause.

    Florida Property Insurance Claim Deadlines

    Florida's current statute sets different notice periods for an initial claim and a supplemental claim.

    Under Florida Statute §627.70132, an initial claim or reopened claim generally must be reported to the insurer within one year after the date of loss. A supplemental claim for additional loss or damage from the same event generally must be reported within 18 months after the date of loss. The statute defines a reopened claim as a previously closed claim reopened at the insured's request for additional costs, and a supplemental claim as additional loss or damage from the same peril under a claim for which timely notice was already provided. (Fla. Stat. § 627.70132)

    Do not wait until the deadline is close. Your policy may require notice in a particular way, and evidence is easier to preserve while the damage is recent. Ask your insurer how to report the loss and keep proof that you did.

    Florida Statute §627.70131 also sets claim-handling requirements. An insurer generally must acknowledge claim-related communications within seven calendar days. After receiving a proof-of-loss statement, it generally must begin a reasonably necessary investigation within seven days, subject to the statute's exceptions. If a physical inspection is involved, the assigned adjuster must conduct it within 30 days after receipt of the proof of loss. The statute generally requires an insurer to pay or deny an initial, reopened, or supplemental property claim, or a portion of it, within 60 days after receiving notice, unless factors beyond the insurer's control prevent it. (Fla. Stat. § 627.70131)

    Those are statutory claim-handling deadlines, not a promise that every claim will be fully resolved within 60 days. The statute includes exceptions and specific rules about what counts as a claim communication, proof of loss, and circumstances beyond the insurer's control. If the insurer asks for more information, respond and keep a copy of what you send.

    What If You Disagree With the Insurance Company?

    Start by identifying the disagreement. Is the insurer disputing the cause of damage? Does it agree there is covered damage but disagree with the scope or cost of repairs? Has it denied coverage for a particular item? Ask for the insurer's written explanation and compare it with the policy language, photographs, contractor estimates, and any engineer or adjuster reports.

    Florida's Department of Financial Services administers a residential property mediation program for eligible disputes between policyholders and insurers. Mediation is an informal process with a neutral mediator. It is nonbinding. The program generally does not cover NFIP claims, claims already in litigation or appraisal, or claims involving a cause of loss that is not covered. Check current eligibility and the application requirements before requesting mediation. (Florida DFS) (Florida DFS)

    A public adjuster is a licensed professional who represents the policyholder in preparing, presenting, or negotiating an insurance claim. A public adjuster is not the insurance company's adjuster. Florida regulates public adjusters and limits compensation. For claims based on an event declared a state of emergency, the statutory cap is generally 10% of claim payments or settlements during the year after the declaration; for other claims, the cap is generally 20%. Special rules apply to reopened and supplemental claims and certain early policy-limit payments. Read the statute and the proposed contract before hiring one. (Fla. Stat. § 626.854)

    You can verify a license through the Florida Department of Financial Services. Do not assume that every contractor, estimator, or consultant who offers to help with a claim is a licensed public adjuster.

    Can You Sell a House With an Open Insurance Claim?

    Yes, a house can be sold while an insurance claim is open. But do not assume the claim or the right to receive future insurance payments automatically transfers to the buyer.

    The insurance policy names the insured parties and may also protect the mortgage lender's interest. If there is a mortgage, the lender may be named as a mortgagee or loss payee on an insurance payment. The NFIP standard policy, for example, provides for building-loss payments to mortgagees of whom the insurer has actual notice, as well as the insured, according to their interests. The actual policy and mortgage documents control. (FEMA NFIP)

    Before selling, contact the insurer and mortgage servicer. Ask what has been paid, what remains open, whether a check has been issued, who must endorse it, whether the lender will hold funds in escrow, and what happens to any unpaid claim amount at closing. Get the answer in writing. A title company can help identify mortgage payoffs and recorded interests, but it cannot decide an insurance coverage dispute for you.

    Florida has also restricted assignments of post-loss insurance benefits. Under §627.7152(13), a policyholder generally may not assign post-loss benefits under a residential or commercial property policy issued on or after January 1, 2023, subject to statutory exceptions. One exception covers an assignment, transfer, or conveyance to a subsequent purchaser of the property who has an insurable interest following the loss. Other exceptions include certain powers of attorney and liability coverage. The statute's effective application depends on the policy issue or renewal date and the law governing that contract. (Fla. Stat. § 627.7152)

    The practical point: do not write into a sale contract that the buyer will receive an open claim or claim proceeds without first confirming that the transfer is legally permitted and accepted by the insurer and lender. Have a Florida real estate attorney review the proposed arrangement.

    What Must You Disclose to a Buyer?

    Florida's Supreme Court held in Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985), that a seller of residential real property must disclose known facts materially affecting the property's value that are not readily observable and are not known to the buyer. The case involved a seller's failure to disclose known roof problems. (Johnson v. Davis)

    For a hurricane-damaged home, that can include known roof leaks, water intrusion, flood damage, mold, structural damage, unrepaired storm damage, or a prior repair that did not solve the problem. Keep the repair invoices, permits, inspection reports, engineering reports, and insurance correspondence. A buyer may ask for them, and accurate records make it easier to explain what happened.

    Florida Statute §689.302 also requires a seller of residential real property to complete and provide a flood disclosure to the buyer at or before execution of the sales contract. The statutory form asks whether the seller knows of flooding that damaged the property during the seller's ownership, whether the seller filed a flood-related insurance claim, and whether the seller received flood-damage assistance, including FEMA assistance. The definition includes overflow of inland or tidal waters, unusual and rapid accumulation of runoff or surface water, and sustained standing water resulting from rainfall. (Fla. Stat. § 689.302)

    The flood disclosure is not a substitute for answering other questions honestly. If you know about material storm damage, disclose it. Ask a Florida attorney if you are unsure how to answer a disclosure question.

    Permits and the FEMA 50% Rule

    If the house is in a Special Flood Hazard Area, major repairs may trigger substantial-damage requirements. Under the NFIP definition, a structure is substantially damaged when the cost to restore it to its pre-damage condition equals or exceeds 50% of the structure's market value before the damage. The land is not included in the structure value. The local floodplain administrator makes the determination under the community's adopted rules. (44 CFR § 59.1)

    A substantial-damage determination can mean the home must be brought into compliance with current floodplain requirements, which may require elevation, replacement, relocation, or demolition depending on the property and local rules. Do not start major work until you understand the determination and permit requirements.

    Read more here: the FEMA 50% rule: rebuild or sell?

    Repair, Claim or Sell: How to Compare the Options

    I would put the decision on paper before choosing.

    Repair the house. Get a written scope and estimate from qualified contractors. Confirm whether permits are needed and whether floodplain rules affect the work. Compare the repair cost with the insurance payment you realistically expect to receive, not just the amount you initially requested. Include the deductible, excluded damage, uncovered upgrades, and the time the work will take.

    Continue the claim. This may make sense when the policy appears to cover a meaningful part of the loss and the claim is still within the statutory deadlines. Keep records and ask the insurer to explain disputed items in writing. If you disagree, consider a licensed public adjuster or an attorney. Neither is automatically necessary in every claim.

    Sell as-is. This may make sense when the repair is too large, the house is difficult to insure, the owner cannot manage the work, or the carrying costs are becoming a burden. A buyer will account for the damage, the work, and the risks. An as-is sale does not erase the duty to disclose known material facts or automatically transfer the insurance claim.

    Compare the likely net proceeds, not just the offer price. Account for mortgage payoff, liens, insurance proceeds you are entitled to keep, repairs, permits, utilities, taxes, insurance, temporary housing, and the time needed to finish the transaction.

    If the house is uninhabitable, carrying costs and temporary living arrangements can become a major part of the decision. Review the policy for additional living expense coverage and ask the insurer what it covers. Do not assume it pays every hotel, rental, or moving expense.

    Two Tampa Bay Situations I Have Seen

    I worked with an out-of-state owner whose vacant Tampa house had been damaged by two hurricanes and then vandalized. A code case also threatened daily fines. Other buyers offered more money, but one would not respond to the changes the seller had requested. I accepted the seller's terms, and the seller chose my offer.

    The lesson was not that the highest offer is always wrong. It was that the seller was weighing more than the headline price. The seller wanted clear terms and someone who would agree to them. If you compare offers, compare the contract, closing date, deposit, inspection rights, assignment language, and who pays closing costs.

    I also know a family that inherited a house worth roughly $500,000 and decided not to sell. The hurricanes flooded it, and the family did not have flood insurance. They eventually sold for about $200,000, roughly the land value.

    That is a painful example of why flood coverage and a realistic plan matter. It is not a prediction of what another damaged house will be worth. Every property has a different location, condition, elevation, insurance history, and repair requirement.

    Selling As-Is Through A+ Home Buyers

    A+ Home Buyers is one option if you decide not to repair the house before selling. We buy single-family homes, townhouses, multifamily properties, and manufactured homes built in 2000 or later when the seller owns the land. Our usual purchase range is $50,000 to $500,000. We do not buy condos, commercial properties, or homes on leased lots. The seller does not have to clean out the house.

    We use the standard Florida AS IS contract with no inspection period. The deposit is $3,000 to $10,000, non-refundable, and delivered to the title company the same or next business day. Closing is usually seven to 14 days or on the seller's date. We use a local title company, usually Majesty Title or Peer Title, and A+ pays the closing costs. Mike's partner funds purchases, so we do not rely on a bank loan or appraisal.

    Mike buys most houses himself. In about one deal in four, he assigns the contract at the same price, closing date, and terms, and the seller knows up front. "The offer we sign is the offer we close."

    Owner Mike Youngblood and partner Erick Alin are both licensed Florida real estate agents. If listing the house is likely to net you more, we can discuss that option instead.

    More information:

    When You Shouldn't Sell to Me

    If the insurance claim is likely to fund repairs and the house can be restored at a cost that makes financial sense, repairing and listing may produce a better result. If you have a strong contractor, a clear scope, and time to manage the work, you may not need a cash sale. And if another buyer offers better terms and a stronger net, take that offer.

    Questions sellers ask

    The short answers.

    Can I sell my hurricane-damaged house while an insurance claim is open?
    Yes, but the open claim does not automatically transfer to the buyer. The policy, mortgage documents, and Florida's limits on assignment of post-loss benefits matter. Before signing, ask the insurer and mortgage servicer how any unpaid claim proceeds will be handled, and have a Florida real estate attorney review any proposed transfer language. Disclose the known damage and claim history to the buyer.
    How long do I have to file a hurricane insurance claim in Florida?
    Under current Florida Statute §627.70132, an initial or reopened property claim generally must be reported within one year after the date of loss. A supplemental claim generally must be reported within 18 months. These deadlines do not replace the policy's reporting requirements, and the statute contains definitions and exceptions. Report damage promptly rather than waiting until the deadline approaches.
    Does homeowners insurance cover hurricane flooding?
    Most homeowners policies do not cover flood damage. Wind damage may be covered under the homeowners policy, while rising water and flood damage generally require a separate flood policy, such as NFIP or private flood insurance. A single storm can cause both kinds of damage. Report the loss to each potentially applicable insurer and ask for a written explanation of how the damage is being classified.
    Do I have to disclose hurricane damage when I sell?
    Florida's Johnson v. Davis decision requires disclosure of known facts that materially affect value and are not readily observable or known to the buyer. Florida Statute §689.302 also requires a flood disclosure at or before contract execution. Keep records of damage, repairs, insurance claims, permits, and reports. If you are uncertain how to answer a disclosure, ask a Florida real estate attorney.
    Should I repair or sell a hurricane-damaged house as-is?
    Compare the repair estimate, expected insurance proceeds, deductible, uncovered work, permits, carrying costs, and likely sale price after repairs with a realistic as-is offer. Repairing may be better when the house can be restored economically and you have time to manage the work. Selling as-is may be worth considering when the scope is large or the property is difficult to manage. Do not decide from the offer price alone.
    Sources for this article
    1. Florida DFS, Hurricane Recovery Resources
    2. Florida DFS, Post-Disaster Insurance Claims guide
    3. Florida OIR, Flood Insurance
    4. Florida Statutes §627.70132, Notice of property insurance claim
    5. Florida Statutes §627.70131, Insurer's duty to acknowledge communications and investigate
    6. Florida DFS, Mediation and Neutral Evaluation
    7. Florida Statutes §627.7015, Alternative procedure for disputed property insurance claims
    8. Florida Statutes §626.854, Public adjusters and fee limits
    9. FEMA, NFIP Flood Insurance Manual
    10. Florida Statutes §627.7152, Assignment agreements
    11. Johnson v. Davis*, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985), Florida Supreme Court docket and opinion
    12. Florida Statutes §689.302, Flood disclosure
    13. 44 CFR §59.1, Definitions

    General information about storm damage, insurance claims and selling in Florida, not legal or insurance advice. Coverage depends on your policy. Talk to your insurer, a licensed public adjuster or a Florida attorney.

    Scroll to Top