Blog · Houses that need work

Selling a house that failed a 4-point inspection.

A failed 4-point doesn't make a house unsellable. It limits which buyers can insure it, and so which buyers can get a loan.

    Get your no-obligation offer

    A real person — usually Mike — calls you back the same day.

    Mike Youngblood

    Mike Youngblood, owner of A+ Home Buyers and a licensed Florida real estate agent. I've read a lot of 4-point reports. Here's what a failed one actually means for a sale. Last reviewed November 10, 2026

    A failed 4-point inspection does not make a house unsellable. It can limit which buyers can get homeowners insurance, and that affects any buyer who needs a mortgage. Before you assume you have to sell at a discount, find out exactly what failed and what it would take to fix.

    This is general information, not legal or insurance advice. Where a rule matters, I've linked the source.

    What is a 4-point inspection?

    A 4-point inspection is a focused look at four systems: the roof, electrical, plumbing, and heating and air conditioning. Insurers may ask for one when you insure an older home. The insurer uses it to judge the age, type and condition of those systems. If an insurer asks for a 4-point and doesn't get one, it may refuse certain coverage or refuse to insure the house. (Florida DFS)

    Citizens Property Insurance requires a 4-point inspection on all property owner, dwelling and mobile home applications for homes more than 20 years old. A Florida-licensed inspector checks the four systems, and serious hazards, like exposed wiring or active leaks, should be fixed before you apply. Other insurers set their own rules. (Citizens)

    A 4-point is not a full home inspection. It's a snapshot of four systems for an insurance decision.

    Why houses fail

    There's no single statewide pass or fail standard. Each insurer sets its own. Start with the report itself.

    Roof. The inspector records the covering, age, condition, visible damage and signs of leaks, and marks the roof satisfactory or unsatisfactory. (Citizens 4-point form)

    Electrical. The report covers the panel and wiring, their age and condition, and any hazards. Exposed wiring is one of the serious deficiencies Citizens says to fix before applying. (Citizens)

    Plumbing. The form records pipe materials, including copper, PVC, galvanized and polybutylene, plus active or past leaks and the water heater. (Citizens 4-point form)

    Heating and air. The inspector records the system type, age and whether it's in good working order. (Citizens 4-point form)

    A failed report doesn't mean every system needs replacing. Ask the insurer which item is the problem and what paperwork would satisfy it. My 4-point readiness check walks through the same four systems.

    Florida's roof-age rule

    Florida law gives homeowners some protection against an insurer rejecting a roof only for its age. An insurer can't refuse to write or renew a homeowners policy just because the roof is less than 15 years old. For a roof 15 years or older, the insurer has to let you get an inspection by an authorized inspector before requiring replacement for age. If that inspection shows at least five years of useful life left, the insurer can't refuse or non-renew just because of the roof's age. (Fla. Stat. § 627.7011)

    That isn't a guarantee of coverage. An insurer can still turn a house down for other lawful underwriting reasons, and the rule doesn't apply to mobile home policies. (Fla. Stat. § 627.7011) If your roof is older, ask the insurer which inspection it will accept.

    Your options

    Fix the one item

    If the report flags one discrete problem, get a written scope and estimate, do the work, and keep invoices, permits and photos for the insurer. Don't replace a whole system until you know that's what's required.

    Ask another insurer

    Insurers don't all use the same underwriting rules. A licensed Florida insurance agent can tell you whether another carrier will take the house as it is.

    A renovation-loan buyer

    Some buyers can roll repairs into the purchase loan. The buyer, the house and the work all have to qualify.

    Sell as-is for cash

    A cash buyer doesn't need insurance or a loan to close. The trade-off is price: the offer builds in the repairs and the risk.

    Renovation loans. FHA's 203(k) program lets a buyer finance repairs into one mortgage. The Limited 203(k) covers smaller repairs, and the Standard 203(k) covers major rehab. (HUD) Fannie Mae's HomeStyle Renovation loan also lets an eligible borrower include repair and renovation costs in a purchase loan. (Fannie Mae) The lender has to approve the borrower, the house and the project.

    I'm not an insurance agent. Get the insurance answer from a licensed professional, not from a buyer's guess.

    Two houses from my files

    Get a clear read before you decide the house needs a cash buyer. Read the full Tampa story.

    What a cash sale looks like here

    I walk the house and make an offer based on its condition. You don't fix the roof, electrical, plumbing or A/C first, because we don't need insurance or a loan to close. We use the standard Florida AS IS contract, with no inspection period. Our deposit is $3,000 to $10,000, non-refundable, and goes to the title company the same or next business day. We usually close in 7 to 14 days, or on your date, at a local title company, usually Majesty Title or Peer Title, and A+ pays the closing costs. The offer we sign is the offer we close. How I come up with the offer.

    When you shouldn't sell to me

    If one repair would make the house insurable and you have time, fixing it and listing will usually put more money in your pocket. If the house is in good shape, list it. A buyer with a renovation loan may also pay more than I can. Erick Alin and I are both licensed Florida real estate agents, so if listing is the better move, we'll tell you, and we can list it. Run both numbers yourself.

    Questions sellers ask

    The short answers.

    Does a failed 4-point inspection mean I can't sell my house?
    No. It means the inspection found something that may affect insurance. You can fix it, ask a licensed agent about other insurers, look for a buyer with a renovation loan, or sell as-is to a buyer who doesn't need a mortgage. The right route depends on what the report actually says.
    Does every insurance company require a 4-point inspection?
    No. Florida's Department of Financial Services says an insurer may require one, usually on older homes. Citizens requires one on homes more than 20 years old. Other insurers set their own rules.
    Does Florida law make an insurer accept my 15-year-old roof?
    Not exactly. An insurer can't reject a roof under 15 years old just for its age. For a roof 15 or older, it has to allow an authorized inspection, and it can't refuse for age alone if the inspection shows at least five years of life left. Other underwriting issues can still matter.
    Can a buyer get a mortgage on a house that failed a 4-point?
    Possibly. It depends on the lender, the insurer and the repairs. FHA 203(k) and Fannie Mae HomeStyle Renovation loans can finance eligible repairs as part of a purchase. The buyer should talk to a lender that offers them.
    Should I replace everything before selling?
    No, not before you know what's required. Get the report, ask the insurer what would make the house acceptable, and get estimates for that specific work. Sometimes one repair solves it. Sometimes the cost and the uncertainty make an as-is sale the better call.
    Sources for this article
    1. Florida DFS: Homeowners Insurance Overview
    2. Citizens Property Insurance: Inspections
    3. Citizens: 4-Point Inspection Form
    4. Fla. Stat. § 627.7011: roof age
    5. HUD: 203(k) Rehabilitation Mortgage Insurance
    6. Fannie Mae Selling Guide: HomeStyle Renovation

    General information about 4-point inspections and selling a house in Florida, not legal or insurance advice. Talk to a licensed insurance agent or a Florida real estate attorney about your situation.

    Scroll to Top