Blog · Cash offers

How far below market value should a cash offer be?

There's no fixed percentage. How to find the right value, what a cash buyer subtracts, how to compare with listing, and what to read beyond the price.

    Get your no-obligation offer

    A real person — usually Mike — calls you back the same day.

    Mike Youngblood

    Mike Youngblood, owner of A+ Home Buyers and a licensed Florida real estate agent. Make the buyer show you the numbers behind the offer. Here's what goes into one, and how to check it yourself. Last reviewed November 10, 2026

    There is no fixed percentage that makes a cash offer fair. A fair offer is what remains after the real costs of buying, repairing, holding, and reselling the house, along with a reasonable return for taking the risk. You can check the math yourself, compare it with a likely listing result, and decide whether the convenience is worth the difference.

    I explain the four main deductions in the video below. The important thing is not to memorize a formula. It is to make the buyer show you the assumptions behind the number.

    How I build a cash offer: the four things I subtract.

    Start with the right value

    The first question is what the house would be worth after the work is completed. That is the after-repair value, or ARV. It is not necessarily what the house is worth today in its current condition.

    Suppose a house needs a roof, flooring, kitchen work, and repairs to an air-conditioning system. A renovated house down the street may be a useful comparison for what yours could be worth after those items are completed. But it is not a direct comparison to the house you are selling today.

    You need to look at two values:

    • As-repaired value: What similar homes in comparable condition have actually sold for.
    • As-is value: What buyers are likely to pay for the property in its present condition, taking the known repairs and other issues into account.

    How to choose comparable sales

    Start with recently closed sales, not just asking prices. Look for homes in the same neighborhood or a genuinely competing area. Compare property type, lot, square footage, bedroom and bathroom count, age, layout, condition, pool, garage, renovations, and location factors such as flood exposure. Fannie Mae's appraisal guidance says comparable sales should have similar physical and legal characteristics and should reflect the same market area and buyer pool where possible. (Fannie Mae, Comparable Sales)

    A renovated three-bedroom home with a new roof and updated kitchen is not a strong comparison for a house with an old roof, dated systems, and deferred maintenance unless you account for those differences. The same goes for a home on a larger lot, a house with a pool, or a property on a busy road.

    Use closed sales as your starting point. Current listings tell you what sellers are asking, not what buyers have agreed to pay. Pending sales can help show where the market is moving, but the final sale price is not yet known. Appraisal guidance also calls for analysis of closed sales, contract sales, and current offerings, with differences considered. (Fannie Mae, Sales Comparison)

    If possible, use three or more good comparable sales rather than relying on one unusually high sale. If the best matches are older or farther away, be cautious about how much weight you give them. A real estate agent can help identify relevant sales, but remember that a buyer's estimate is still an estimate. It is not a guaranteed resale price.

    What does a cash buyer subtract?

    A buyer who plans to repair and resell a house has to account for more than the difference between the purchase price and the future sale price. The basic calculation looks like this:

    Estimated resale price - repairs and renovation - holding costs - resale and closing costs - allowance for unexpected problems and risk - buyer's required profit

    = maximum purchase price the buyer can justify

    The exact numbers should be specific to the property. Here are the main categories.

    1. Repairs and renovation

    This is often the biggest variable. A buyer needs to estimate what it will cost to make the house marketable and address the problems that affect value or safety.

    That may include a roof, HVAC, plumbing, electrical, windows, flooring, paint, kitchen, bathrooms, landscaping, pool repairs, permits, or cleanout. A cosmetic renovation is different from correcting structural damage or replacing major systems.

    Ask the buyer to show you the repair assumptions. If the buyer says the house needs $40,000 in work, ask what that includes. Is it based on contractor bids, an inspection, a walkthrough, or a rough estimate? Does it include permits, disposal, contingency, and work that may be discovered after demolition?

    You do not have to agree with the buyer's estimate. You can get your own contractor opinions. A large repair deduction based on vague language deserves a closer look.

    2. Holding costs

    The buyer may own the house for weeks or months while repairs are completed and the property is marketed. During that period, the buyer may pay:

    • Property taxes.
    • Homeowners or vacant-property insurance.
    • Electricity, water, and other utilities needed to protect or work on the house.
    • Lawn, pool, pest, and basic maintenance.
    • Loan interest, points, or other financing costs, if the buyer borrows money.
    • Security and other costs of keeping the property protected.

    These expenses are real, but they vary. A buyer using cash may not have the same financing costs as a buyer using a short-term loan. A house needing extensive work may take longer to resell than one needing paint and flooring. Ask how long the buyer assumes the project will take and which carrying costs are included.

    3. Resale costs

    The buyer also has costs when the renovated property is sold. These may include real estate brokerage compensation, title and settlement charges, documentary stamp taxes, recording charges, and concessions negotiated with the next buyer.

    There is no single commission rate that every seller or buyer must pay. Brokerage compensation is negotiable, and the parties decide what services and compensation they agree to. (NAR)

    The resale estimate should not assume that every future buyer will pay every closing expense. The buyer may need to offer a concession or adjust the price to get the property sold. That is a business risk the investor considers when making the purchase offer.

    4. Profit and risk

    A buyer is operating a business. The buyer needs a return that makes the project worth the capital, time, and uncertainty involved. That is part of the calculation.

    But "profit" should not be a magic word that ends the conversation. Ask whether the buyer has already included a contingency for repairs, a longer holding period, or a lower resale price. If the buyer subtracts a large risk allowance and then adds another large contingency, make sure those are not charging you twice for the same uncertainty.

    A buyer may also have a different exit plan. One buyer may renovate and resell to an owner-occupant. Another may rent the house. Another may hold it as an investment. Their costs and target returns will differ, so two legitimate buyers can arrive at different offers for the same property.

    Is there a standard investor formula?

    You may see real estate investors discuss rules of thumb based on a percentage of the after-repair value. Those formulas are screening shortcuts. They are not appraisals, and they do not tell you what a particular Tampa-area house is worth.

    I do not price a house by applying one fixed percentage to its after-repair value. The condition, scope of work, location, likely resale price, carrying period, and title issues all matter. A simple percentage can be too low for a house needing little work or too high for a property with expensive, uncertain repairs.

    Instead, ask for the actual numbers. A buyer who cannot explain the resale value and main deductions is asking you to accept a number without understanding it.

    Compare the cash offer with listing

    The right comparison is not the cash offer against the highest possible listing price. It is the cash offer against what you are likely to keep after selling costs, repairs, and time.

    A listing calculation might look like this:

    Likely sale price - agreed listing brokerage compensation - any buyer-broker compensation or concessions you agree to pay - title, settlement, documentary stamp tax, and other seller closing costs - repairs or buyer credits - mortgage, tax, insurance, utility, and maintenance costs while you wait - moving, cleanout, or other property-specific expenses

    = estimated net proceeds from listing

    Commissions are negotiable, and a seller can decide whether to offer compensation to a buyer's agent or other concessions. Those decisions should be made with the listing agent and reflected in the agreement and offer. (NAR)

    Then compare that estimate with the cash offer after any debt or liens that must be paid. Use the same assumptions for both paths. If you include a roof repair in the listing estimate, do not forget it when calculating the cash buyer's offer. If you assume the cash buyer pays closing costs, do not subtract those same costs from the cash side.

    You can use the Cash vs. Listing Calculator to organize the comparison. I also recommend reading Cash Offer vs. Listing: How to Actually Compare the Two Numbers.

    The market price is not guaranteed. A listing can attract competing buyers and produce a higher price, but it can also take longer, require repairs or concessions, or fail to close. A cash sale may offer a more predictable contract and closing date, but the purchase price is usually lower because the buyer is taking on the work and resale risk.

    Why can offers on the same house be so different?

    Different buyers may see different values in the same property. One may have a contractor who can do the work efficiently. Another may expect a full renovation. One may believe the house can be resold quickly. Another may expect a longer holding period or a lower resale price.

    Their business models also differ. Some buyers intend to purchase and renovate the property themselves. Others negotiate a contract and assign their contractual interest to another buyer. In an assignment, the assignor may earn money from the difference between the contract price and the amount the end buyer agrees to pay. The seller should understand who is signing the contract, whether assignment is permitted, and what the seller's price and terms will be.

    At A+ Home Buyers, I buy most houses myself. About one deal in four, I assign the contract at the same price, closing date, and terms. The seller knows up front. The seller's agreed price does not change because of the assignment.

    If you are comparing an investor, an iBuyer, and a wholesaler, their business models can help explain why the offers differ. See iBuyer, Wholesaler or Investor: How Each Makes Money.

    Look beyond the purchase price

    A higher offer is not necessarily the better offer if the buyer can later reduce it, walk away easily, or delay closing. Compare the contract terms, not just the first page.

    Look at these items:

    • Deposit: How much is deposited with the title company? When is it due? Is it refundable, and under what circumstances?
    • Inspection period: Can the buyer cancel or renegotiate after inspecting the property? How long does that right last?
    • Closing costs: Which costs does the buyer pay, and which remain with you?
    • Closing date: Is the date specific? Can the buyer extend it? Does it work with your move or other obligations?
    • Price changes: Does the contract allow the buyer to reduce the price after inspections, title review, or another condition?
    • Assignment: Can the buyer assign the contract? If so, do you know who will ultimately be responsible for closing?

    Read the actual contract. Do not rely only on what the buyer said during a phone call. A+ uses the standard Florida AS IS contract with no inspection period. The deposit is $3,000 to $10,000, non-refundable, and delivered to the title company the same or next business day. We usually close in 7 to 14 days, or on the seller's date, and we pay the closing costs.

    Our promise is: "The offer we sign is the offer we close." That does not mean you should skip reading the agreement. It means the written price and terms matter. For more on this issue, read Can a Cash Buyer Change the Offer After You Sign?.

    A house I told the owners not to sell to me

    A brother and sister inherited their father's Tampa home through probate. The brother lived in Nashville. The house was dated, but it was in great shape. It had a pool and a newer roof.

    I looked at comparable homes and believed the property would sell well on the open market. I told them that listing would likely net them more than my cash offer. They cleared out the furniture and had the house professionally cleaned. It went under contract quickly and sold for $15,000 over asking.

    That is the kind of decision a seller should be able to make with clear information. A fair buyer should be willing to tell you when the cash offer is not your best option. You can read the full account here: Sold in 7 Days, $15,000 Over Asking: How We Helped a Tampa Family Sell an Inherited Home.

    How A+ Home Buyers approaches an offer

    I look at the house, its condition, the work it needs, and the likely resale value. We do not use one fixed percentage of market value. We make an offer based on the property and the costs and risks involved.

    If listing is likely to put more money in your pocket, my partner Erick Alin and I are both licensed Florida real estate agents, and we can discuss listing instead. I would rather you understand the difference than accept a cash offer that does not make financial sense for you.

    A+ Home Buyers buys single-family homes, townhouses, multifamily properties, and manufactured homes built in 2000 or later on land the seller owns, usually between $50,000 and $500,000. We do not buy condos, commercial properties, or homes on leased lots. You do not have to clean out the house.

    We usually close in 7 to 14 days, or on your date, through a local title company, usually Majesty Title or Peer Title. We pay the closing costs. My partner funds the purchases, so we do not rely on a bank loan or appraisal. Call (813) 200-7665 or visit 8401 N 40th St, Suite A, Tampa, FL 33604.

    If you want to understand the offer calculation in more detail, start with How Do You Come Up With Your Offer?.

    When you shouldn't sell to me

    If the house is in good condition and comparable sales support a strong listing price, listing may leave you with more money after expenses. If you can afford the time and work, making a few targeted repairs before listing may improve your result. If another buyer offers a better net and equally solid contract terms, take that offer seriously. A cash sale is a trade-off between price, certainty, timing, and the work you want to take on.

    Questions sellers ask

    The short answers.

    How much below market value should a cash offer be?
    There is no standard discount that makes an offer fair. Start with the realistic resale value of the house in its repaired condition, then subtract the actual repair budget, holding costs, resale costs, and a reasonable return for the buyer's capital and risk. Compare that result with the likely as-is value and with what you would net from listing. The buyer should be able to explain the assumptions.
    Why is a cash offer lower than a listing price?
    A cash buyer is usually taking responsibility for repairs, holding expenses, and resale risk. The buyer also expects a return for investing money and time. A listing price, by contrast, is an asking price before commissions, closing costs, repairs, concessions, and carrying costs. Compare your likely net proceeds, not the cash offer against an unadjusted asking price.
    Should I get more than one cash offer?
    Yes, if you have time. More than one offer can help you see how different buyers value the property and estimate the work. But compare the written terms as well as the price. Check the deposit, inspection or cancellation rights, closing date, closing costs, assignment language, and any provision that allows the price to change. A higher number is not useful if the buyer cannot or will not close on the agreed terms.
    Can a cash buyer lower the offer after signing?
    That depends on the contract. Some agreements give the buyer an inspection or due-diligence period during which the buyer may cancel or seek a price change. Other agreements limit those rights. Read the signed contract and any addenda. Do not assume that "cash" means the price cannot change. See Can a Cash Buyer Change the Offer After You Sign?.
    Is a cash offer better than listing?
    It depends on your priorities and the property's condition. A cash offer may provide a clearer closing path and avoid the need to repair or clean out the house. Listing may produce a higher sale price, especially when the property is in good condition and buyers are competing for it. Estimate the net proceeds from both options, include the time and costs involved, and choose the one that best fits your circumstances.
    Sources for this article
    1. Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-08, Comparable Sales
    2. Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-07, Sales Comparison Approach Section of the Appraisal Report
    3. National Association of REALTORS®, Consumer Guide: Offers of Compensation

    General information about how cash offers are calculated, not financial or legal advice. Every house and offer is different.

    Scroll to Top