Blog · Cash or list?
Cash offer vs. listing: how to actually compare the two numbers.
The useful number isn't the offer or the list price. It's what you keep after costs, repairs, concessions and time.
Mike Youngblood, owner of A+ Home Buyers and a licensed Florida real estate agent. I buy houses for cash and I list them, so I have a stake either way. Here's how I actually compare the two. Last reviewed November 10, 2026
When a seller asks whether to take a cash offer or list, I'm in an unusual spot. I buy houses for cash, and I'm also a licensed Florida real estate agent. So is my partner, Erick Alin. We can make an offer, or we can list the house when that will put more money in your pocket.
I have a financial interest either way, which is exactly why the comparison has to be honest. The highest number isn't always the best deal, and a cash offer isn't automatically the right answer. The useful number is what you actually keep.
Why sellers consider cash instead of listing
When someone asks me about cash versus listing, the price gap is rarely the only concern. Most of the time it's condition: they assume the house can't sell because it needs work. Sometimes they don't want strangers walking through. Sometimes the house is cluttered or dated, and putting photos online is uncomfortable.
Those are real concerns. A direct sale makes sense when certainty, privacy or a set closing date matter more than the last dollar. But if the house can be financed, you have time, and the market price is a lot higher, listing is usually the better money decision. I'll say that even when it means I don't buy the house.
What it actually costs to list
| Cost | What to include |
|---|---|
| Commission | Negotiated with the agents. No percentage is required. |
| Closing costs | Title charges, doc stamps, recording and other contract costs. |
| Concessions | Credits or costs the seller agrees to cover for the buyer. |
| Repairs | Work required or negotiated after inspections. |
| Preparation | Cleaning, landscaping, photos, staging, moving things out. |
| Holding costs | Mortgage, taxes, insurance, utilities, lawn and pool while it's listed. |
Concessions are the line sellers forget. In my recent MLS sales, buyers have asked for them regularly. The amount depends on the house, the market and the buyer's loan.
Sometimes the price is raised to cover the credit. If a buyer wants a $6,000 concession, the parties might write $206,000 with a $6,000 credit instead of $200,000 with none. That only works if the appraisal and the buyer's loan support the higher price. It doesn't create value by itself.
Commission is negotiable. Compensation isn't set by law. (NAR) Get the services and fee in writing before you sign.
Holding costs run the whole time. On one of my listings, that meant insurance, property taxes, the TECO bill, water, pool and yard maintenance, every month. Here's the full cost breakdown.
What repairs can cost after an inspection
This is where a listing gets more expensive than planned. On an inherited Tampa house I listed, inspections turned up:
| Roof: a few shingles and an unsecured vent cap | about $900 |
| Plumbing: water shutoff valve | about $350 |
| A/C: failed, replaced | about $7,500 |
| Septic tank: cracked, failed inspection | about $15,000 |
| Total | about $24,000 |
The A/C mattered most, because the buyer needed insurance to get the loan. The sellers replaced it. The septic was handled with a repair holdback: money held by the closing agent at closing, with the work done afterward and the contractor paid from escrow. A holdback has to be agreed to and documented; it isn't automatic.
If those sellers couldn't have paid for the A/C, I'm not sure the sale closes. Get real estimates before you decide. More on failed 4-point inspections.
How long it takes to sell in Tampa
A cash sale is faster because there's no lender appraisal, underwriting or loan approval. We usually close in 7 to 14 days, or on your date, once title work is ready.
A listing depends on price, condition, demand and the buyer's financing. A well-priced house can draw a quick buyer. A house that needs work, or is priced above what buyers think it's worth, can sit.
Case study: listing beat my offer by about $50,000
The lesson isn't that listing always wins. It's that you compare the real numbers. The higher price came with repairs, concessions, and the time and risk of a listing. These sellers had the money and the patience to make that trade.
Here's that deal side by side:
| My cash offer | $340,000 |
| Sold for | $464,000 ($15,000 over asking) |
| Repairs | about $24,000 |
| Net after concessions, commission, closing costs and repairs | about $390,000 |
| Difference | about $50,000 more by listing |
Why a cash offer can be more certain
A financed offer has several steps to clear: the inspection period, the appraisal, insurance and final loan approval. Any one can delay the sale or kill it.
A real cash purchase doesn't depend on a lender approving the buyer or the house, and there's no appraisal. My partner funds our purchases. We use the standard Florida AS IS contract, with no inspection period. Our deposit is $3,000 to $10,000, non-refundable, and goes to the title company the same or next business day. We usually close in 7 to 14 days, or on your date, at a local title company, usually Majesty Title or Peer Title, and A+ pays the closing costs. The offer we sign is the offer we close.
That doesn't mean you take any cash offer without checking. Get proof of funds and read the contract.
Do cash offers fall through?
Yes. "Cash" on an offer doesn't guarantee the buyer has the money or intends to close.
The undisclosed wholesaler. I buy most houses myself. About one deal in four, I assign the contract at the same price, closing date and terms, and the seller knows up front. The warning sign isn't assignment itself. It's an assignment the seller doesn't understand, or a long inspection period used to shop the contract and renegotiate.
The tiny deposit. A buyer with a few hundred dollars down has little at risk.
Money that isn't really there. If a "cash" buyer actually needs a hard-money loan or another lender, find out before you sign.
A buyer who hasn't seen the house. A high offer from someone who hasn't walked it may come with a plan to inspect later and ask for less.
How to tell if a cash buyer is legitimate
Proof of funds
The money should be available to close, now.
Inspection terms
A long due-diligence period gives the buyer time to reconsider or renegotiate.
Assignment
Ask whether they plan to assign, and whether your price and terms can change.
The buying entity
Search the LLC in public records and look at its track record.
The deposit
Amount, when it's due, who holds it, and whether it's refundable.
The title company
A reputable one handles the closing. It doesn't replace your own legal advice.
Our deposit is $3,000 to $10,000, non-refundable under the contract, and at the title company the same or next business day. Read the contract and ask questions before you sign. The 3 lines to check in any cash offer.
When cash beats listing, and when it doesn't
Cash may make sense when
The house needs repairs you can't afford or don't want to manage. A financing or insurance problem makes a regular sale hard. You need a reliable date. You want no showings or prep.
Listing may make sense when
The house can qualify for normal financing and insurance. Market value is meaningfully higher than the cash offer. You can pay for repairs and carry the house. You have time.
Sometimes neither is best. If the house is in good shape and the numbers work, keeping it or renting it may be worth a look.
Get a realistic listing net sheet and a written cash offer, and compare what you'd keep. How I come up with my offer.
When you shouldn't sell to me
If your house is in good shape, you have time, and listing will likely net you substantially more, list it. If you can afford the repairs and the carrying costs, there may be no reason to take a cash discount. I'd rather tell you that up front than buy a house you'd have been better off listing.
Questions sellers ask
The short answers.
Is a cash offer always lower than a listing price?+
How quickly can A+ Home Buyers close?+
Does A+ Home Buyers ever assign a contract?+
Do I have to clean out the house before selling for cash?+
Should I get a cash offer and a listing estimate before deciding?+
Related reading
Sources for this article
General information about selling a house in Florida, not legal, tax or financial advice. Figures in the examples are from Mike's own transactions, not market averages.
Want both numbers side by side?
Send the address. Mike will walk the house and give you his cash offer and what he thinks it would sell for listed, after costs.
