The higher offer wasn't the better offer
The biggest number on page one isn't always the best offer. Clear terms matter. How to tell a wholesaler from an investor.
Blog · Before You Sign
Mike Youngblood, owner of A+ Home Buyers and a licensed Florida real estate agent. I've watched plenty of sellers get a lower number two weeks in. Here's how it happens and how to see it coming. Last reviewed November 10, 2026
A buyer can't simply rewrite a signed purchase contract because they changed their mind. But the contract may give the buyer a right to cancel, and that right can become leverage to ask for a lower price. Before you sign, know what the buyer can do, when the deposit is due, and whether the buyer can assign the contract.
This is general information, not legal advice. Have a Florida real estate attorney review any contract term you don't understand.
A late price cut is sometimes called a "retrade." The buyer signs at one price, then comes back asking you to take less. Sometimes there's a real reason. Sometimes it's a sign the offer was never as firm as it looked. Here's where it usually comes from:
An inspection period. The Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS contract gives the buyer an inspection period, 15 days if the blank is left empty. During it, the buyer can cancel if the property isn't acceptable in the buyer's sole discretion, and gets the deposit back. (AS IS contract, ¶12) A buyer can use that window to ask for a lower price. You don't have to agree, but while the window is open, the buyer can walk.
Other conditions. Read every rider and addendum. Financing, appraisal, association approval or title conditions can all give the buyer a way out. "Cash offer" doesn't mean "no conditions."
A small or refundable deposit. The deposit is how much the buyer has at risk. A deposit that's small, late, or refundable under a broad cancellation clause means walking away costs them little. The contract decides whether it's refundable, not a verbal promise.
A buyer who doesn't have the money. Some "cash" buyers still need a partner's approval, a lender, or another buyer. Ask where the money is coming from and whether the person signing is the person closing.
An assignment you didn't understand. In an assignment, the original buyer hands the contract's rights and obligations to another buyer. The FR/Bar contract has you check boxes for whether the buyer can assign and whether the original buyer is released from liability. (Florida Realtors) Assignment isn't automatically bad. You just need to know about it before you sign.
Paragraph 12 of the current AS IS contract is titled "Property Inspection; Right to Cancel." The buyer gets the inspection period written in the blank, or 15 days if it's left empty. If the buyer decides the property isn't acceptable and sends written notice before the period ends, the contract is cancelled and the deposit is returned. (AS IS contract, ¶12)
That's why "as-is" doesn't mean "the buyer can't cancel." The buyer's right to walk during the inspection period is broader than a major defect. Addenda can change the standard terms, so read the whole contract.
Inspection period
How many days? Can the buyer cancel for any reason during it? Is there a separate due-diligence or approval clause?
Deposit
How much, who holds it, when it's due, and when it can be refunded. A deposit already at the title company is different from one due next week.
Closing date
Is it firm, or can the buyer extend it? Does anything in the contract let it slide?
Closing costs
Who pays which costs: title, doc stamps, recording, estoppels. Compare your net, not the headline price.
Assignment
Can the buyer assign the contract? If so, is the original buyer released from liability?
For the short version, see the 3 lines to check in any cash offer.
Don't agree on the phone just to keep the deal alive. Ask for the change in writing, with the reason, and compare it with the contract and any inspection report.
Read the termination and default terms. If the buyer can still cancel, you can negotiate or let them go. After the inspection period ends, other terms may still matter.
Ask the title company whether the deposit arrived and how it's held. The title company follows the contract; it doesn't decide disputes.
Talk to a Florida real estate attorney if the buyer threatens to cancel, disputes the deposit or says you're in default.
You don't have to accept a lower price. Decide with a clear view of the contract and your options.
The biggest number on page one isn't always the best offer. Clear terms matter. How to tell a wholesaler from an investor.
We use the standard Florida AS IS contract, with no inspection period. Our deposit is $3,000 to $10,000, non-refundable, and goes to the title company the same or next business day. We usually close in 7 to 14 days, or on your date, at a local title company, usually Majesty Title or Peer Title, and A+ pays the closing costs. The offer we sign is the offer we close. My partner funds the purchases, so there's no bank loan and no appraisal. I buy most houses myself. About one deal in four, I assign the contract at the same price, closing date and terms, and the seller knows up front. What to expect when you sell to us.
If you have time, the house is in good shape and listing would net more, list it. If another buyer offers more and is just as clear and firm on the terms, take that offer seriously. Pick the best mix of net proceeds, certainty and timing, not just the biggest number. Compare cash and listing side by side.
Questions sellers ask
Related reading
General information about Florida purchase contracts, not legal advice. Talk to a Florida real estate attorney about your contract.
Send the address. Mike will walk the house and give you an offer with no inspection period and a non-refundable deposit.