Seller guide · Florida insurance
Florida Home Insurance Too Expensive? Keep the House or Sell?
A big premium jump or a nonrenewal notice changes the math on keeping a house. Check your options first, then put keeping and selling side by side.
5.0 ★
52 Google reviews
20+ Years
Experience
1,000+
Houses walked
Licensed
Florida agents
Florida premiums
What's happening with Florida insurance.
The numbers depend on who's counting. Insurify estimated Florida's average homeowners premium at $8,292 in 2025, up 18% from 2024, and projects about $8,458 by the end of 2026. That's an independent estimate, not a quote. (Insurify)
State data for Tampa Bay is lower. The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation uses actual policy data. As of March 31, 2026, average premiums including wind were about $3,525 in Hillsborough, $4,063 in Pinellas and $2,756 in Pasco. (FLOIR, July 2026)
Citizens rates went down in 2026. Citizens' approved 2026 changes for HO3 multiperil policies were −5.5% in Hillsborough, −5.7% in Pasco and −7.0% in Pinellas. (Citizens 2026 Rate Kit) That's Citizens only. It doesn't mean private carriers cut rates too.
Why your premium is what it is
The roof comes first. Insurers look at its age, material and remaining life, and many ask for a 4-point inspection of the roof, electrical, plumbing and HVAC. (Florida DFS) Under § 627.7011, Fla. Stat., an insurer can't refuse to write or renew a policy because of roof age alone if the roof is under 15 years old. For an older roof, an authorized inspector can certify it. If it has at least five years of useful life left, age alone isn't a reason to refuse. If an inspection turned up roof, electrical or plumbing problems, read selling a house that failed a 4-point inspection.
Wind mitigation features earn credits. Roof-to-wall clips or straps, how the roof deck is attached, and a secondary water barrier can lower your wind premium under § 627.0629, Fla. Stat. (FLOIR wind mitigation)
Flood is separate. A standard homeowners policy doesn't cover flood. If your house is in a high-risk flood zone and has a federally backed mortgage, federal law requires flood insurance. (42 U.S.C. § 4012a) Look up your address on FEMA's flood map.
Your claims history follows the house and you. Insurers check past claims through the C.L.U.E. database, which generally goes back seven years.
Ways to lower the bill before you decide
- Get a wind mitigation inspection. A certified inspector documents clips, straps, shutters and impact windows so your insurer can apply the credits.
- Shop the market. An independent agent can compare carriers, coverage and deductibles. FLOIR's CHOICES tool shows sample rates by carrier.
- Look at your deductibles. A higher hurricane or all-perils deductible lowers the premium, but only if you could cover it after a claim.
- Check My Safe Florida Home. The state program has offered free wind mitigation inspections and grants for hardening work. Funding comes and goes, so check the program FAQ.
- Fix small 4-point items. A contractor estimate on an old panel or a supply line may cost less than a year of higher premiums.
If you get a nonrenewal notice
Read the notice. It has to be in writing and state the reason. Note the date coverage ends.
Don't let coverage lapse if you have a mortgage. Your servicer can buy force-placed insurance and bill you. It usually costs much more and protects the lender, not you. Get replacement coverage before the old policy ends.
Check Citizens. If no private carrier will cover you, or a private offer costs more than 20% above Citizens for comparable coverage, you're generally eligible for Citizens through an appointed agent. (Citizens eligibility)
Keep or sell: put the numbers side by side
Add up what the house costs you each month: mortgage, property taxes, homeowners insurance, flood insurance, utilities, HOA or CDD, and upkeep. Say that comes to $3,450 a month. That's $41,400 a year. If the house also needs a roof to stay insurable, add that too.
Then compare it with what you'd net from a listing after repairs and from an as-is sale. If you're keeping a house you don't want and the costs keep climbing, every month can take a bite out of your equity. The cash vs. listing calculator runs both.
How insurance affects a sale
Financed buyers need a policy before closing. Their lender requires proof of homeowners insurance. A bad roof or old electrical can stop that buyer from getting insured, and the sale with it.
A cash buyer doesn't need a lender's approval. We buy as-is and price the repairs into the offer, so there's no insurance binder to wait on. You trade some price for speed and certainty. Mike Youngblood and Erick Alin are licensed Florida agents. If your house is insurable and listing nets you more, we'll tell you.
What you can count on
Mike walks it himself
One visit, then a written offer, usually the same day, with the math shown.
No inspection period
The price you sign is the price you get.
Real money on the line
A $3,000 to $10,000 non-refundable deposit at the title company the same or next business day.
Cash or list, honestly
Mike and Erick are licensed Florida agents. If listing nets you more, we'll say so.
Where to check
Who handles what for your insurance.
Start with these before you decide anything. Your agent and your own policy have the final word on your coverage.
Compare rates
FLOIR CHOICES
The state regulator's tool shows sample homeowners rates by carrier and county.
Last resort
Citizens Property Insurance
Florida's state-backed insurer, for homes the private market won't cover at a reasonable price.
Hardening
My Safe Florida Home
The state program for wind mitigation inspections and hardening grants, when funded.
Flood
FEMA flood maps
Look up your address to see whether it's in a high-risk flood zone.
How a cash sale works
Four stages, and most of the work isn't yours.
What sellers say
All 52 reviews →★★★★★
I'm in Ohio and was selling my father's house in Florida. A+ Home Buyers made a fair cash offer to buy the house as is. They work with a great title company that made the process simple to understand and easy.
Bob Kemmerle· Google review★★★★★
I needed to sell as is… he explained every step of the process and was very gracious. It only took nine days from initial contact until closing.
Vickie Fernandez· Google reviewInsurance questions
What sellers ask us.
Can an insurance company refuse coverage because my roof is old?+
What should I do if my policy is nonrenewed or canceled?+
Can I get Citizens if no private carrier will cover me?+
Does a 4-point inspection affect my insurance?+
Should I replace the roof to keep the house, or sell as-is?+
Sources for this page
- Insurify: 2026 Florida Home Insurance Report
- Florida Office of Insurance Regulation: Property Insurance Stability Report, July 2026
- Citizens Property Insurance: Revised 2026 Rate Kit
- Citizens Property Insurance: Get a Policy (eligibility)
- Florida Department of Financial Services: Homeowners Insurance Overview
- Florida Statutes § 627.7011: roof age and insurability
- Florida Statutes § 627.0629: wind mitigation credits
- FLOIR: Wind Mitigation Resources
- FLOIR: CHOICES homeowners rate comparison
- 42 U.S.C. § 4012a: flood insurance purchase requirement
- FEMA Flood Map Service Center
- My Safe Florida Home: FAQ
General information about Florida homeowners insurance, not legal or insurance advice. Check your own policy and options with a licensed insurance agent.
Insurance making the house hard to keep?
Send the address. Mike will walk it, show you the math, and tell you honestly whether keeping it, listing it or a cash sale makes the most sense.
