Blog · Title problems
Selling with a judgment, mechanic's lien or second mortgage.
How title finds liens, when a judgment attaches, Florida's construction lien deadlines, second mortgages and HELOCs, and when the debts outrun the house.
Mike Youngblood, owner of A+ Home Buyers and a licensed Florida real estate agent. A recorded lien is a claim, not a verdict. Here's how each of these three works, and what it takes to clear them at closing. Last reviewed November 10, 2026
A judgment lien, a contractor's lien, and a second mortgage can all affect a Florida home sale. In many transactions, the amounts are paid from the seller's proceeds at closing, but each type of lien works differently. Some can also be negotiated, disputed, or released for less than the amount claimed.
The first step is to find out exactly what is recorded against the property and whether it is actually enforceable against that property. A recorded document is important. It is not always the end of the discussion.
How the title company finds liens
When a sale is opened, the title company examines the public records affecting the property. It reviews the chain of title, recorded mortgages, construction liens, judgments, tax liens, and other recorded claims. It may also search the names of the sellers and other relevant parties for judgments or liens that could affect title. Florida law requires recording in the county where the real property is located for a judgment to become a real-property lien there. (Fla. Stat. § 55.10)
If the title company finds a mortgage, it requests a payoff statement from the lender. If it finds a judgment or construction lien, it identifies the recorded document and contacts the lienholder for a payoff, satisfaction, release, or other resolution. The closing agent uses the written payoff figures to prepare the settlement statement and send the agreed amounts to the creditors from the sale proceeds.
Do not rely on an old account statement as a closing payoff. The amount may include accrued interest, fees, legal expenses, or other charges. A title company needs current written instructions from the creditor and a recordable release or satisfaction after payment.
A name search can also produce a false match. For example, a judgment against another person with the same first and last name may appear in the search. The title company may ask for more information to establish that the seller is not the judgment debtor. Depending on the title insurer's requirements, that can include a sworn non-identity affidavit and facts distinguishing the two people, such as different addresses or other identifying information. Do not sign an affidavit unless every statement is accurate. (Sample non-identity affidavit)
The title company is not deciding that you owe the money simply because a name appears in a search. It is deciding what it needs to insure the buyer's title. Ask for the actual recorded document, case number, recording reference, and creditor information. Then you can determine whether it belongs to you and what needs to happen next.
Judgment liens in Florida
A money judgment does not automatically become a lien on every house owned by the person named in the judgment. Under Florida Statute §55.10, a certified copy of the judgment, order, or decree must be recorded in the official records or judgment lien record of the county where the property is located. The judgment or a simultaneously recorded affidavit must also contain the address of the person who has the lien. When those requirements are met, the judgment becomes a lien on the debtor's real property in that county. (Fla. Stat. § 55.10)
For judgments recorded on or after July 1, 1994, the initial real-property lien period is 10 years from the recording date. The lien may be extended for another 10 years by recording a certified copy again before the existing lien expires and simultaneously recording an affidavit with the creditor's current address. But there is an outer limit: a judgment cannot remain a lien on property beyond 20 years from the date the judgment was entered. The recording and extension dates matter, so do not assume an old judgment has expired just because it is more than 10 years old. (Fla. Stat. § 55.10; Fla. Stat. § 55.081)
What if the house is your homestead?
Florida's Constitution generally protects a qualifying homestead from forced sale to satisfy ordinary judgment debts. It also says that most judgments do not become liens on homestead property. But the protection has important exceptions, including taxes and assessments, obligations contracted for the purchase, improvement, or repair of the property, and certain labor performed on the real estate. (Fla. Const. Art. X, §4)
That distinction matters. A credit-card judgment is not the same thing as a judgment arising from an unpaid obligation for work that improved or repaired the home. A contractor's claim may fall within a constitutional exception when the underlying obligation qualifies. Whether the property is legally homestead, and whether the debt falls within an exception, can require a legal analysis of the facts.
Even when you believe a judgment cannot attach to your homestead, the title company may still ask for documentation before it will insure the sale without an exception for that judgment. It may require a release, a court order, evidence establishing homestead status, or another form of clearance acceptable to its underwriter. That is a title-insurance requirement, not a statement that every judgment is enforceable against homestead.
If the name is a false match, provide the title company with accurate identifying information and ask what form of proof its underwriter will accept. If the judgment is yours but you believe homestead protects the property, speak with a Florida real estate attorney before assuming the lien can be ignored.
Mechanic's liens: contractor, subcontractor or supplier
A mechanic's lien is also called a construction lien. Florida law gives certain people who provide labor, services, or materials for improving real property a potential lien right if they are not paid. Depending on the arrangement, that can include contractors, subcontractors, sub-subcontractors, laborers, and material suppliers. A subcontractor or supplier may have lien rights even if the owner paid the general contractor. (Fla. Stat. § 713.01; Fla. Stat. § 713.06)
For many lienors who do not contract directly with the owner, serving a Notice to Owner is a prerequisite to perfecting a lien. The notice generally must be served before work begins or within 45 days after the lienor begins furnishing labor, services, or materials, and before the owner's final payment under the statutory conditions. The notice itself is not a lien. It alerts the owner that the person may later claim a lien if unpaid. (Fla. Stat. § 713.06)
The 90-day deadline to record a claim of lien
A claim of lien generally must be recorded no later than 90 days after the lienor's final furnishing of labor, services, or materials. The claim must identify the lienor, the person who hired the lienor, the property, the owner, the work or materials, the dates of furnishing, and the unpaid amount. The claim must also be served on the owner in the manner required by law. (Fla. Stat. § 713.08)
A recorded construction lien generally lasts one year from the date it is recorded unless the lienor starts a lawsuit to enforce it within that period. If the lawsuit is filed and the lien is continued, a notice of lis pendens is important to preserve its effect against later purchasers and creditors without notice. Do not assume that a lien disappeared just because the one-year date passed; check whether an enforcement action was filed. (Fla. Stat. § 713.22)
Can the owner shorten the deadline?
Yes. Under §713.22(2), the owner or the owner's attorney can record a Notice of Contest of Lien. The clerk serves the notice on the lienor. The lienor then has 60 days after service to file an action to enforce the lien. If the lienor does not file within that period, the lien is extinguished automatically. This is a formal statutory procedure. Do not confuse it with sending the contractor a letter saying that you dispute the bill. (Fla. Stat. § 713.22)
What if the lien amount is exaggerated or no work was done?
Florida law treats a lien as fraudulent if the lienor willfully exaggerates the amount, willfully includes work not performed or materials not furnished, or prepares the claim with willful and gross negligence amounting to willful exaggeration. A minor error or a good-faith dispute over the amount does not automatically make a lien fraudulent. A court can declare a fraudulent lien unenforceable, and the statute provides a damages claim and potential attorney's fees and costs for a prevailing party. (Fla. Stat. § 713.31)
If you dispute a construction lien, gather the contract, invoices, payment records, permits, notices, photographs, messages, and evidence of what work was actually done. Ask the title company what it needs to clear the lien. If the lien is not released voluntarily, a Florida construction or real estate attorney can evaluate whether to challenge it, bond it off, or use another procedure.
Second mortgages and HELOCs
A second mortgage is a loan secured by the house behind the first mortgage in priority. A home equity line of credit, or HELOC, is also commonly secured by a mortgage. When you sell, the title company requests a payoff from each lender. The first mortgage and the second mortgage or HELOC are normally paid from the closing proceeds, and the lenders provide the documents needed to release their liens.
A HELOC can require extra attention because the borrower may still have the ability to draw money. Tell the lender that the property is being sold, ask for its exact payoff and closing instructions, and ask how and when the line will be frozen or closed. Federal Regulation Z allows a creditor to prohibit additional advances or reduce the credit limit in specified circumstances, including a significant decline in the home's value, a material change that reasonably makes repayment doubtful, or a material default. The regulation does not mean every HELOC is automatically frozen as soon as a sale is planned. (12 CFR 1026.40)
Do not keep drawing on a HELOC after requesting a payoff. A new advance can change the amount needed to close and may invalidate an earlier payoff quote. Follow the lender's written instructions and have the title company confirm the final amount shortly before closing.
What if the house is worth less than the two loans?
If the sale price is not enough to pay both mortgages and the other closing costs, the seller cannot simply transfer the property and leave the second mortgage behind. The second lienholder must agree to release its lien for less than the full balance, or another legally valid resolution must be reached. This is often called a short sale or negotiated lien payoff.
The lender's written approval needs to say what amount it will accept and what happens to the remaining debt. A lien release and a waiver of personal liability are not necessarily the same thing. Ask whether the agreement releases only the mortgage lien or also forgives any deficiency. Florida law allows a court to consider a deficiency judgment in a mortgage foreclosure, subject to the statute and the circumstances. (Fla. Stat. § 702.06)
A first-mortgage foreclosure can cut off a junior mortgage lien if the junior lienholder is properly made a party and receives the required process. But if the junior lienholder is omitted, its lien is not extinguished simply because the first mortgage was foreclosed. A subordinate lienholder also has statutory redemption rights before the foreclosure sale reaches the cutoff in §45.0315. This is one reason a second lienholder may consider a negotiated payoff, but it is not a reason to assume the lien will disappear. (Abdoney v. York; Fla. Stat. § 45.0315)
When the liens add up to more than the house
Sometimes no realistic sale price will pay every creditor in full. Start with the current payoff amounts, not the balances shown on old statements. Then compare the total debt and closing expenses with a realistic sale price.
Possible paths include negotiating reduced payoffs, seeking a short sale approval, disputing a lien that is invalid or does not attach to the property, or consulting a bankruptcy or real estate attorney about available options. A buyer cannot make a valid lien disappear just by agreeing to purchase the house. The lienholders must be paid, release their interests, or be dealt with through a legally effective process.
If a mortgage foreclosure is already underway, the court schedule matters too. See How to Stop a Foreclosure in Florida and What Actually Works at the Last Minute. For a broader explanation of liens, see Can You Sell a House With a Lien on It in Florida?. If the issue involves solar financing, see Selling a House With a Solar Panel Lien in Florida. You can also read Sell a House With Title Problems.
Two examples from my work
A woman in Pinellas County was in foreclosure. She owed about $100,000 on the mortgage and had a $10,000 lien from a roof she had installed. She thought the lien made selling impossible. I offered $150,000. The mortgage and the roof lien were paid at closing, she walked away with money, and we closed in two weeks.
In a probate in Bradenton, a mother had signed a contract with a window company before she died. No work had been done and no money had changed hands, but the contractor recorded a lien for about $20,000. The heir contacted the company and asked it to release the lien. They agreed and asked only for a five-star Google review.
The lesson is not that every recorded lien is invalid or that every creditor will negotiate. It is that a recorded lien is a claim, not a verdict. You need to find out what supports it, what the law requires, and what the lienholder will accept.
How A+ Home Buyers can help
I buy houses in the Tampa Bay area, including Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco counties. If you are considering selling with a judgment, construction lien, or second mortgage, we can review the title issues with the closing company and determine what payoffs or releases are needed. We use the standard Florida AS IS contract with no inspection period. The offer we sign is the offer we close.
We usually close in 7 to 14 days, or on the seller's date, through a local title company, usually Majesty Title or Peer Title. We pay the closing costs. The lien balances still have to be addressed, and there must be enough money or an agreed resolution to close with insurable title.
I do not recommend selling if another option leaves you in a better position. My partner Erick Alin and I are both licensed Florida real estate agents, so we can also discuss listing if that is likely to net you more. We buy single-family homes, townhouses, multifamily properties, and manufactured homes built in 2000 or later on land the seller owns. We do not buy condos, commercial properties, or homes on leased lots. You do not have to clean out the house.
Call (813) 200-7665 or visit A+ Home Buyers at 8401 N 40th St, Suite A, Tampa, FL 33604. If you are unsure whether a judgment or lien is legally enforceable, talk with a Florida real estate attorney. I am not a lawyer, and a title company cannot replace legal advice.
When you shouldn't sell to me
If the judgment is a false match or the lien is invalid, it may be better to clear the record before selling rather than accept a lower price. If the home is in good condition and the debt can be paid from a normal market sale, listing may leave you with more money. If a second mortgage lender will not approve a short payoff, an attorney may be able to help you evaluate other options. A cash sale is useful in some situations, but it is not the right answer for every owner.
Questions sellers ask
The short answers.
Does a judgment automatically become a lien on my Florida house?+
How long does a judgment lien last in Florida?+
How long does a contractor's lien last?+
Can I sell my house if I have a second mortgage or HELOC?+
Does a Florida homestead protect my house from every judgment or contractor lien?+
Related reading
Sources for this article
- Florida Statutes §55.10 — Judgments; lien on real property; extension
- Florida Statutes §55.081 — Statute of limitations, lien of judgment
- Florida Constitution, Article X, §4 — Homestead exemptions
- Florida Statutes §713.01 — Definitions
- Florida Statutes §713.06 — Liens of persons not in privity; proper payments
- Florida Statutes §713.08 — Claim of lien; 90-day recording deadline
- Florida Statutes §713.22 — Duration of lien; Notice of Contest
- Florida Statutes §713.31 — Remedies in case of fraud or collusion
- Florida Statutes §702.06 — Deficiency decree; foreclosure
- Florida Statutes §45.0315 — Right of redemption
- 12 C.F.R. §1026.40 — Requirements for home equity plans
- Abdoney v. York, 2005 — Effect of foreclosure on omitted junior lienholder
- Florida title-agent sample non-identity affidavit
General information about Florida liens and judgments, not legal advice. Talk to a Florida real estate attorney before relying on homestead protection or disputing a lien.
Lien on the house?
Send the address. Mike will work through the payoffs with the title company and tell you what you'd walk away with.
