Before you sign a cash offer

7 things to watch for from a cash buyer.

It's rough out there for sellers. Here's what national buyers and small operators do to cut your price after you say yes, and what to ask before you sign anything.

    Get your no-obligation offer

    A real person — usually Mike — calls you back the same day.

    Mike Youngblood

    Mike Youngblood, owner of A+ Home Buyers and a licensed Florida real estate agent. I buy houses for cash, so I see what other buyers put in front of sellers.

    I'm a cash buyer, and I'll be honest: a lot of what goes on in this business worries me. I've sat with sellers who signed with someone else first and found out too late that the price was going to change, the buyer was never going to buy, or the deposit was a hundred dollars.

    Investors comb public records for foreclosures, divorces and deaths, and look for signs of trouble like water shut-off notices. (ProPublica) AARP says older homeowners are a frequent target. (AARP) If you're getting letters, calls and texts about your house, this is for you.

    Read all 7 before you sign with anyone. Including me.

    Who's making the offer

    Two kinds of cash buyers.

    National buyers

    Instant-offer companies (iBuyers) and large investor-backed firms. They price by algorithm and buy at volume. Large institutional investors own about 15% of the single-family rental market in Tampa, according to a federal GAO report. (NLIHC, GAO) The risk with them is mostly fees and repair credits.

    Smaller operators

    The "We Buy Houses" signs, mailers and cold texts. Some are honest local investors. Many are wholesalers who sign your house to sell the contract. The risk with them is a contract that lets them walk, wait or cut the price.

    How to tell whether you're talking to a wholesaler or an investor.

    The 7 warning signs

    What to watch for, and what I do instead.

    1

    National buyers

    The number shrinks after you say yes.

    Some large buyers lead with a strong offer, then take a service fee and repair credits out of it before closing. One industry study put iBuyer convenience fees at 6% to 9.5%, and the total cost to the seller at 13% to 15% of the home's value. (Inman, Collateral Analytics study) Smaller operators do a version of this too: closing costs or transfer taxes quietly deducted from the contract price. (ProPublica)

    What I do instead: No service fee. A+ pays the closing costs. The offer we sign is the offer we close.

    2

    National buyers

    An algorithm prices it. An inspection reprices it.

    A computer estimate gets you to yes. Then an inspector walks the house, and the repair list becomes a price cut. The same study found these buyers often ask for generous repairs based on the inspection, and its fee figures didn't even include those repair credits. (Inman)

    What I do instead: Mike walks your house himself before he makes an offer. There's no inspection period after you sign, so there's nothing to reprice.

    3

    Smaller operators

    The buyer never meant to buy your house.

    Some contracts let the buyer market your property and assign the agreement before closing. (ProPublica) That means they're selling your contract to someone else for more, and some never tell you. AARP describes the same pattern: sign the homeowner, then sell the contract to an investor. (AARP)

    What I do instead: Mike buys most houses himself. About 1 deal in 4, he assigns the contract, at the same price, closing date and terms, and you know up front.

    4

    Smaller operators

    A long inspection period, used to shop your house.

    A 14- or 30-day inspection window can be a way to hold your house off the market while the buyer looks for someone to flip the contract to, or builds a list of reasons to pay less. In many wholesale contracts, the buyer alone holds the right to cancel. (ProPublica)

    What I do instead: We use the standard Florida AS IS contract with no inspection period.

    5

    Smaller operators

    A deposit too small to matter.

    ProPublica found contracts with deposits as low as $100 on a $157,000 house. (ProPublica) A buyer with $100 at risk can walk away the week before closing, after you've stopped looking for anyone else.

    What I do instead: Our deposit is $3,000 to $10,000, non-refundable, and it goes to the title company the same or next business day.

    6

    Smaller operators

    "Cash" that's really a loan.

    Some "cash" buyers are borrowing from a hard-money lender or waiting on an investor's money. If that money falls through, so does your closing. Ask where the money comes from, and ask for proof of funds before you sign.

    What I do instead: Mike's partner funds our purchases. There's no bank loan and no appraisal.

    7

    Both

    Pressure to sign today, from someone who hasn't seen the house.

    "Sign now" is the oldest move there is. One attorney ProPublica interviewed called a same-day signing demand a huge red flag. (ProPublica) AARP warns about homeowners being asked to sign on a phone, which leaves little room to read. (AARP) A high number from someone who never walked the house usually comes with a plan to cut it later.

    What I do instead: Take our contract home. Show it to your family or an attorney. The offer will still be there.

    Ask every buyer

    Six questions. Compare the answers.

    Ask thisRed flag answerA+ answer
    Can the price change after I sign?Yes, if there's an inspection period or repair clause.No. No inspection period. The offer we sign is the offer we close.
    Are you buying it, or selling my contract?They dodge it, or the contract allows assignment without saying so.Usually we buy it. About 1 in 4 we assign, same terms, and you know up front.
    How much is the deposit, and when is it due?A few hundred dollars, or refundable.$3,000 to $10,000, non-refundable, at the title company the same or next business day.
    Where is the money coming from?A lender, a partner, or "we'll find a buyer."Mike's partner. No bank loan, no appraisal.
    Who pays closing costs?You do, or they come out of the price.A+ pays them.
    Can I take the contract to an attorney first?"This price is only good today."Yes. Take your time.

    Also read the contract for three things: language that lets the buyer "cloud" your title, a clause giving only the buyer the right to cancel, and debts or costs "subtracted from the final price." (ProPublica)

    When you shouldn't sell to me

    If your house is in good shape and you have time, listing it will often net you more than any cash offer, including mine. My partner Erick Alin and I are both licensed Florida real estate agents, so I'll show you both numbers. If another buyer gives you better terms in writing, with a real deposit and no inspection period, take it.

    Questions sellers ask

    The short answers.

    Are all cash buyers like this?
    No. Plenty of investors are honest, and a cash sale is the right call for a lot of houses. But the bad practices on this page are common enough that you should check for every one of them before you sign, including with us.
    Is wholesaling legal in Florida?
    Assigning a purchase contract is generally legal. What hurts sellers is not knowing it's happening, or a contract built so the buyer can walk or cut the price while you wait. Ask directly, and read the assignment and cancellation clauses.
    Why would a buyer record something against my house?
    Some investors record a memorandum of the contract, which can tie up your title even if you find a better buyer. ProPublica calls this predatory but usually legal. Watch for contract language that lets the buyer "cloud" your title, and ask a Florida real estate attorney before you sign.
    What if a cash offer isn't my best option?
    Then don't take it. Mike and his partner Erick Alin are both licensed Florida real estate agents. If listing will net you more, Mike will show you the math and tell you so.
    How do I get an offer from A+?
    Send the address with the form on this page, or call (813) 200-7665. Mike will walk the house, explain every number, and give you a written offer you can take home.
    Sources for this page
    1. ProPublica: Looking to Sell Your Home for Cash? Read This First (May 17, 2023)
    2. AARP: AARP Tackles Predatory ‘We Buy Homes for Cash’ Offers
    3. Inman: iBuyers cost sellers up to 15% of a home’s value, study finds (Aug. 8, 2019)
    4. National Low Income Housing Coalition: summary of GAO-24-106643, Institutional Investment in Single-Family Homes

    General information, not legal advice. Have a Florida real estate attorney review any contract before you sign.

    Scroll to Top